Recruitment Reviews

Help Us Help The Community

We are committed to protecting our community from fraudulent submissions that might affect our ratings and reviews.

We review and approve every post before it appears on our site, and in the case that the community sees something suspicious we will look into the issue and take appropriate action.

 

Important read first - What is a Credible review on ESLwatch?

 

We will not post reviews containing:

3rd party experiences ie. "he said, she said" , "on behalf of", "my mate worked at this institute" scenarios or writing on behalf of a colleague.

  • Rants, venting, or obscenities
  • Personal insults or defamatory attacks (by name, title, or association)
  • Aggressive or discriminatory language
  • Trade secrets or information protected by employer contracts
  • Content not relevant or helpful to our community
  • Text in ALL CAPS or using excessively poor grammar

Please read our Community Guidelines for more information about our review criteria.

FAQ's & Legals

 

As always, ESLwatch guarantees our users anonymity. This means YOU can feel secure there will be no repercussions when you post reviews or comment on reviews.

 

 

 

Open Panel

Search ESLwatch

Log in Register

Login to your account

Username *
Password *
Remember Me

Create an account

Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.
Name *
Username *
Password *
Verify password *
Email *
Verify email *
Captcha *

Your trust is our top priority, institutes are not allowed to alter or remove their reviews.

Institute reviews can be submitted anonymously by employees, students, parents or even if you have had an interview. Read employee reviews and ratings on ESLwatch to decide if an institute is right for you.

 

How would you rate your experience at this insitute?

China in Asia (Recruitment): JESIE - Recruiter - ChinaJiangsu Provincial Department of Education (JESIE) is a recruiter located in China.

 

Address: Room 2212 Jiangsu Education Mansion, #15 West Beijing Road, Nanjing, P.R.C. Zip: 210024

Website English: Jiangsu Provincial Department of Education (JESIE)

2.3/5 from 3 ratings.
  • Experience
  • Professionalism
  • Work location
  • Living situation
  • Pay & benefits
  • Support & facilities
  • Health & safety
Summary rating
Reviewer
1 rating(s).
1 helpful voted.
Terrible
1 months ago.
Experience
Professionalism
Work location
Living situation
Pay & benefits
Support & facilities
Health & safety
Institute Review
Think carefully before picking this one
The cons
I am going to apologize in the beginning for the length of this review. I endured a year of torture with JESIE, so please understand I will have a lot to say. To begin, my arrival day with JESIE was the day they take the pictures. I was not informed of this until the evening before when I was in the airport in Hong Kong. L at JESIE told me I need a formal outfit that is full black. As I had sent all of my formal clothes home recently due to never having used them, I told her I had nothing to wear. She told me to go ahead and wear my darkest colored jeans and top as the photographer could edit my clothes. Well, when I arrived I felt like an idiot because everyone was dressed very nicely except me of course. I also found out (unbeknownst to me) that the previous week was a training week. I had missed the entire training, though there wouldn’t have been anything I could do about that anyway because I was under a contract in Hong Kong and left the day it finished. Well, I expected someone at JESIE would catch me up with what I missed. Boy, was I wrong. I got a 15 minute run down of what people spent an entire week on before I was sent off to my school. JESIE is very particular on the structure and curriculum they want you to use, but I got no information about that beforehand. This caused a lot of problems later on which I will mention.
In regards to my school, I had a lot of issues. The apartment was particularly bad. First, there was a serious mold issue. The mold was growing uncontrollably on the walls. I noticed this in early October. I reported this to JESIE and the school multiple times. They finally said they would fix it during the winter holiday (middle of January) as they needed to paint and didn’t want the paint fumes to bother me. Since this was the best they could do, I agreed and lived in the moldy apartment, trying to clean it best as I could during that time. I also had a problem getting any help at the school. My electricity got cut off once because no one would give me the number for the utilities to pay even though I asked numerous times. It also took me more than 1 month to be able to get wifi. I had to bring my laptop to the school every day to do work that was necessary for my job. In the end, my Chinese boyfriend had to set up the wifi for me because the school wouldn’t do anything. I reported all of this to JESIE. I got no help at all. There were also some serious attitude problems. There was a teacher in the school the previous year who had left after half a year. This was the first foreign teacher to work at the school. My coworker was discussing this with me and basically complaining that the girl was always asking for help to buy things that were necessary to live, like groceries. She told me that no one wants to help us because it’s extra work that they don’t get paid for. I was shocked, but of course it made sense as to why I never got any help from my school, even for things they were responsible for. I also had two issues in which I had called my liaison, one being when I was sick and one being when there was an issue with an exam, and she laughed at me and mocked me on the phone. The issue with the exam was this: It was the last week before winter holiday and of course the school had just informed me about giving exams. I was nearly finished, but I had 3 more exams to give and one final day. The school decided they wanted to start regular exams that day and take my cla*s*s, but they still wanted me to give my exams. I told them they need to tell me when and what day. They couldn’t manage to think of a day and time. After considering it a while, we decided I would do it during the lunch hour of the same day they cancelled my cla*s*s (hope that makes sense). Well, I come to the cla*s*s during the lunch hour and guess what? The head teachers 1. Didn’t know I was coming and 2. Said I couldn’t have the class. I called my liaison and told her I was quite upset about this. Clearly, they don’t take things seriously as I do. There were also several occasions when I received a call in the morning around 7 am and the school told me I didn’t need to come that day. Then, about 20 minutes before class began, they called me and told me they changed their minds and I needed to go! I hadn’t even taken a shower yet or gotten ready. They told me I could just do it later, which isn’t even the point. This school had no idea of how to work with foreigners. What professional teacher wants to go to class looking a mess? Not me! In addition to these issues, I had a very hard time with discipline in the classroom. Many of the kids would be violent with one another, yanking each other out of their chairs and bashing the other one’s head on the floor. I had one student throw glass at another student. I tried to discipline them through the m*t*ods recommended to me, but it never worked. Sometimes the students would just run out of my class and around the side of the building. I would call for them to come back and they wouldn’t. I couldn’t get any help with my cla*s*s from JESIE or the school. It was a nightmare, but I personally tried my absolute best.
Now, for the part about JESIE. I definitely feel I was targeted by JESIE as they treated me as an outcast and picked on me. These are the reasons why. So, after the first half of the year’s issues, I had come back from winter holiday and found that the mold issue had not been touched at all. We had training that week at the JESIE headquarters and we were supposed to have a meeting with P the boss. I decided I would mention my issues at this time. At the advice of my friends, I was told to tell her that if this is not fixed, then I will be leaving. So, the meeting finally came and I told her that I was generally dissatisfied. I was also planning on telling her about the other above mentioned issues with my school, but we didn’t get that far. I said what I wanted to say about the mold, and she went off on me. She was completely yelling at me, criticizing me as a teacher. She was saying how I didn’t meet JESIE standards as a teacher. So, let me add in here that my cla*s*s had been observed officially by the academic supervisor V only twice up to that point and they were done during the FIRST MONTH of the year when I hadn’t even received the training everyone else had! Of course, I questioned her why this was not brought up before and also why more reviews hadn’t been done on my cla*s*s. She told me that, yes, she should have told me sooner and that she told V to stop coming to review my cla*s*s because I asked him why he came to my school… Apparently I missed the training in the manners class where it wasn’t appropriate to ask someone the reason for their visit as CLEARLY I had a reason to worry. She also proceeded to criticize me for not doing more than my required peer observations. The entire time I was with JESIE, I did every task they asked of me. I did every essay, every peer observation, everything…and I did it on time or early. She was actually criticizing me for not doing MORE when I already had an inflexible schedule, the travel is at MY cost, and there are many other things I have to complete for them and my school. I’m still stunned by this. She also berated me for getting upset at L 2 times on the phone because the address and directions she gave me for other teacher’s schools were not correct and I was nearly late. She told me that other teachers give the office staff gifts and bring in food that they baked, etc. She also told me that, due to my teaching, they didn’t trust me to do open days. I had done one so far the entire 6 months. V was present for that open day and I asked her what the feedback for that open day was. Unsurprisingly, she didn’t know anything about my performance that day. She was basing my performance on her own assumptions and not on reality. I did not get to discuss any of my issues with P. I listened to her berate me for 30+ minutes instead. Without even having a full understanding, she then told me “Well, I can see you won’t choose us next year and we won’t choose you either.” The funny part of this is that I was actually still considering staying with them depending on how this meeting went. Clearly, this was no longer an option for me.
After the meeting, of course I began to look for a new job. However, I tried to improve my standing in JESIE’s eyes as best as I could to leave on a good note. I apologized to L and gave her a gift. I made brownies and brought them to the office. I observed 2 cla*s*s outside of the one I was assigned that month. V came to see my class again in April. The report said that I did meet standards. I received 2 in the first month of working and then one in April, 2 months before the end of the year. I wonder how long this false impression was going on before it was corrected because no one cared to check on my teaching?
Well, did any of this improve anything with JESIE? No. They still treated me terribly. They caused a HUGE amount of problems for me in transferring to my new job. At first, they wouldn’t give me a document that I needed to transfer. Then, they gave me the document so late that we didn’t have enough time to complete the transfer of my residence permit. My new company asked them multiple times if they would extend my current residence permit, but they refused. So, we had to start from scratch. They really caused huge problems for me. I cannot express how horrible and stressful the year was working for them and the nightmares they caused for me as I was leaving.
I know this has gotten long, but I just want to end by saying this. More than half of the teachers they had last year left. There’s a reason for that. In the very least, I hope this makes you think hard and ask a lot of questions before working at this company. I certainly don’t want anyone to deal with this again.
Institution Location
Nanjing
Show more
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
Horrible experience
10 months ago.
Experience
Professionalism
Pay & benefits
Health & safety
Institute Review
I committed to JESIE (Jiangsu Provincial Department of Education) with the agreement that I would teach 4th or 5th grade. I later learned, after arrival, that I would be teaching 1st and 2nd grade and have one 5th grade class twice a week. They pulled this bait and switch on another teacher who had just arrived from the States. He thought he was going to teach high school -- after arrival, he learned he would teach 3rd and 4th grade.

After telling me where I would work and that it was final, I was shuttled to my school, which was in a suburb outside Nanjing. (I had been led to believe that I would work in Nanjing proper.) I was put up in a dorm (no kitchen, just a bathroom and bed), and even when I prot*s*ed they didn't lift a finger. After getting really sick twice, I realized that my contract only permitted two sick days for the whole 10 month period. I was stuck working sick for a few weeks.

After arguing with them, I was taken to the Chinese hospital, which was bad experience to say the least. JESIE was extremely rude to me as well. I was told that they had to provide extra help (as thought I weren't living up to my side of the agreement) because I didn't know how to teach English to children. But the truth is, I didn't come to China expecting to teach first graders (who are really one year younger than 1st graders in America).

After three months, and persistent worsening of my health, I left in the morning on a flight back to America. I got two emails after I left. One threatening me, ridiculing me, and saying they would put me on the Chinese Blacklist, so that I would never again be able to work in China.

The second email was addressed to me and all my fellow co-workers in which JESIE called my departure “irrational, illogical, and irresponsible.” They said that they reported me to the police, too. As though I am a wanted fugitive for leaving a job. This company is performing bait and switch on a regular basis.

They also purport themselves as a government agency, but this website has it right. They are simply a recruitment agency and an unethical one at that. I am glad I left. And I have since gone to the doctor and a specialist for my health condition, which was my reason for leaving.
The pros
They paid me 10,000 Yuan per month and they paid me on time. And I initially felt quite positive about my situation, but then things went downhill. I can't think of much else beyond that.
The cons
I went to the hospital 4 times in China and they never reimbursed me once. In my contract it explicit says they will provide me with reimburs*m*nt and insurance. They don't even do this.

They are now trying to be more present on social media to con more English speakers into coming to Nanjing on false promises.
Advice to Management
Be more considerate and value your employees. Don't bait people to get on a plane and come to China only to switch their working agreement once they arrive.

The email that was sent to me after I left, was a scare tact for other employees not to leave, and I saw it as a punitive measure. I left for health reasons. They would do better being considerate and wishing me a quick recovery back in the United States, instead of erupting in anger.
Institution Location
Not close to the location where I was led to believe I would work. They say they don't know exactly where you will work because it depends on the school that they place you at. But I was put out in the sticks, which again was not what they led me to believe..
Show more
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful
  • alexisstrand 1 months ago.
    I was working at JESIE during the time this happened and JESIE led all of us to believe (Name removed Admin) was an evil teacher who led some kind of crazy nightlife and this is what he got sick from. They told us they did as much as they could to help him and that the tests at the hospital told him there was nothing to be concerned about. They said that because he was still worried, they were just about to go with him to the hospital again before he left without any notice. They painted a very different picture. Clearly, (Name removed Admin) was sick for weeks and there was som*t*ing very wrong. They lied to all of us because they didn't want us to see they failed to help a teacher that was suffering. He obviously left because he had no choice. BTW, I hope they read this comment
Reviewer
1 rating(s).
2 helpful voted.
Good Schools Can Get Scammed Too!
2 years ago.
Experience
Professionalism
Work location
Living situation
Pay & benefits
Support & facilities
Health & safety
Institute Review
It's hard to know who's telling the truth these days. In the midst of my job search for China, I got an email from a recruiter "Allen" who was trying to copy JESIE - i.e., JESIE's email address is teachinjiangsu@hotmail.com and the copycat's email was teachinjiangsu@163.com. I had earlier seen a list of information describing the credentials of the real JESIE (see above) including their license number on eslteachersboard.com so I was impressed. It happened that I got the copycat's email who asked me if I can arrive in Zhengzhou within a week as that was his job offer - when his contract was for a university/website in Changzhou. He then sent me a contract which is authorized by "Nafea" not "Safea" which of course I turned down. After that, although I contacted the real JESIE as I was impressed by the credentials listed on eslteachersboard.com, I continued my research about all the schools, including JESIE. Unfortunately I found the latest trick: disgruntled teachers, posing as well-meaning warners, blackening the name of a school: http://www.eslbase.com/forum/viewtopic/t-2267 so I turned down JESIE's offer! When I read further about this character "Suzhou Teacher Also" who posted the "bad review" about JESIE, I realized the mistake I made and contacted JESIE again and thankfully they're still interested after my blunder. 
The pros
I have yet to continue the steps in the job consideration, but the first interview went well. She thanked me for telling her about the copycat and the troll!
Show more
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
  • Tarzan 2 years ago.
    In China nobody is immune from scams and impersonation. Anything goes to make a buck here. I suggest that everyone who is coming to China make themself 100% scam-proof by reading the stickies in the forum here https://eslwatch.info/en/eslwatch-forum/china.html

Adding Your institution is Easy as 1-2-3

Simply add your institution, the form only takes a few minutes.

Register yourself on the website confirm that you are a human. Wait for confirmation via email.

Once you login to the website you can then review your chosen institution.

Recently Added

The Castle Language School is a private school located in Barcelona, Spain. Address: calle Martí Julià, 94, (esquina calle Montseny),...
RSA Academies has number of private schools located in United Kingdom. Address: Head Ofiice - 8 John Adam St, London, WC2N...
JiLin Province Tianshuo Education Exchange is a company located in Changchun, China. Address: Room 1928 Unit A Of The International...
JILIN Younovo Education is a privite school located in Changchun, China. Address: Room 398, Floor 3, 3766 Yatai Grand Street,...
Panyathip International School (PIS) has a couple of private schools located in Laos. Address: Kindergarten School - Saphanthong Tai Village, Sisattanak...
Bevy English Center is a private school located in Hanoi, Vietnam. Address: Bill Gates School, Lot X1 North Linh Dam...
LeWaijiao (TAL Education Group) is an online website located in Haidian, China. Address: Haidian, China. Website: LeWaijiao (TAL Education Group)...

Connect With Us Today

We believe it’s important to stay closely connected with the great individuals and organizations in the ESL/EFL industry, and what better way than through social media? We’re constantly posting updates online and participating in the buzz.

Please consider connecting with us on the following social media websites to stay up-to-date and connected!

 

Select a Country

Have you added your Institution!

Add your institution for review!

Thank for using ESLwatch, just one more thing before you go. Have you added your institution for review?

Does not matter if it is a school, college, university, recruiter, company, individual or online website that you have had dealings with in the past or present. The review form only takes a few minutes and you do not have to review the institution yourself.

 

Add Your Institution for Review

x